Finishing, Publishing, and Maintaining Your Book
22 Reviewing and Completing the Text
Rachael Nevins
Your book will benefit from careful reviews, including by other sets of eyes than your own. In this chapter, you will learn about some ways to have your book reviewed before you deem it complete.
Peer Review
Asking a colleague—a peer—to review your book before publication is one way to get helpful feedback from an expert. Consider what you hope to learn from their perspective to set expectations for the review. Here are some suggestions.[1]
- Use a rubric that informs the reviewer about the feedback you are seeking. Download and adapt our rubric template, if you wish.
- Provide an introduction to the book that includes a description of its intended audience and purpose.
- Clarify that you are seeking the reviewer’s expertise on the content, but do not need help with grammar, spelling, layout, or other aspects of the book.
- Consider giving the peer reviewer only a portion of the text, not the whole book.
- Give the reviewer adequate time to conduct the review and set a deadline.
Funding from the CUNY OER Initiative is available to support peer review. Contact your campus OER representative to ask about these funds.
Student Review
When you first use your book in the classroom, consider inviting your students—your target audience!—to provide feedback on the text. This review may be informal, or you might adapt a rubric like the following one:
| Description | Needs Improvement | Good | Exceeds Expectations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complete | I think that information is missing because I am unsure what I should be learning. | All information is given, and I know what I am supposed to be learning. | Examples and/or descriptions are complete; I do not think I am missing information. |
| Clear | I am unsure what I should learn from the topic; the examples and descriptors are unclear. | It is clear to me what I am supposed to learn about this topic. | Examples and descriptions connect to what I am supposed to learn about the topic. |
| Concise | There are too many words with sentences saying the same thing in a slightly different way. | There are just enough words, and the sentences are clear. | The sentences are short and to the point, with examples and media that ensure I know the point of what I am learning. |
| Cohesive | The topics jump around and do not follow a logical and in-order presentation. I am not sure how the topic matches the chapter content. | The topics follow a logical order with the entire chapter and chapter outcomes. | The topics are logical and in order, and the flow of the chapter from start to end makes sense to me. |
| Courteous | The tone of the writing comes across as angry, too matter-of-fact, or confusing. | The tone of the writing is pleasant to read. | The tone of the writing is pleasant, and I want to learn more. |
The Final Review
After you incorporate any changes suggested by reviewers, it’s time for the final review of the text. Although it is not ideal, it is possible to proofread your own work, finding and correcting infelicities in diction and usage, typographical errors, misspellings, wrong or missing punctuation, and other problems you had previously overlooked. The following tips will help:
- Put the book aside for a couple weeks so that you can look at it with fresh eyes.
- Change the look of the book to further defamiliarize the text. Change the font, for example, or print out a PDF export to mark up by hand.
- Break down the task. Don’t try to proofread the entire text all at once.
- Review the text more than once, checking for a particular type of error each time. You might check the style and content of image captions in one review, citations in another review, and then the main body of the text in yet another review, for example.
- Read aloud. Reading aloud slows you down, and you might hear what your eye would otherwise skip over.
- The bulleted list of suggestions is excerpted and adapted from Peer Review in the BCcampus Open Education Self-Publishing Guide by Lauri M. Aesoph, published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The rubric template provided for download is by the CUNY Office of Library Services. ↵