16 Working in Black and White for Drama
Dr. Jessica Boehman and Elijah Sy

Why Black and White?
I love working in black and white. It’s dramatic. It can be subtle. It forces you to not hide behind anything flashy, like color. It forces you to learn how to use value well in your drawings.
However, I find one of two things when teaching young illustration students: either they are hesitant to use black and white, or they are hesitant to work in color. Both are worth mastering, and you should have examples of both color and black and white work in a good illustration portfolio.
I find the key to working well in either is understanding two things: the limitations of the palette (in black and white, it’s white, black, and the greyscale), and the proper use of value to draw attention to the subject matter and to preserve its readability.

Pen and black ink, with brush and black wash, over graphite, on tan wove paper, 1893. The Art Institute of Chicago.
Above, I show you two very different illustrations in black and white: the first, by John Martin, is a mezzotint etching of a Biblical scene, whereas the second is a stylized ink drawing using pen and brush by Aubrey Beardsley. John Martin is heavy-handed in his use of greyscale to give an image of nighttime lit by a dramatic light at upper right: a miracle at Belshazzar’s feast where a Godly message is written on the wall, warning Belshazzar against the worship of idols. The viewer’s eye is directed first to the bright light, the warning on the wall, then across the sky to the lightning, and lastly, to the crowds of people cowering in fear within the confines of the palace.
Beardsley, on the other hand, eschews greyscale entirely. A purely black and white work, the closest he comes to grey tones is by creating pattern in the hair of the tempting women, the bark of the tree, and in the small details of Sir Bors’ armor and in the leaves of the tree. He leaves large sections of both stark black and white, adding balance to the image. He is not afraid of either extremes of the value scale.
Think about value
When working in black and white, or, in black and white plus greyscale in particular, you must not be afraid to use pure blacks and pure whites. The point of greatest contrast in any image will be the place the eye wants to land, so practice putting light next to dark in the most important spot. Beware of having all of your values fall within the midrange. This will create “mud.” The picture won’t pop and it will be hard to read.
Notice, for instance, in the Beardsley drawing above. The black that encircles Sir Bors’ head draws attention right to him. He keeps the sky behind the heads of the temptresses white so we can focus on their faces and hair.
A good rule of thumb is to look at lots of images. All good images use value in a proper way.
Look to the masters for examples of value done right
You can compare old master paintings with desaturated, black and white versions of the paintings, to get a sense of how value that works in color can work well in black and white.
Below, here is the famous Madame X by John Singer Sargent. As a painting, it’s nearly perfect. In color, it is luscious and seductive. It stands larger than life.

Now, look at this painting and try to determine the points of value. Where is the point of greatest contrast? How do the lights and darks draw your eye around the picture? You want to think similar things when composing your images with value in mind.
Here is the same image, brought into greyscale.

Do you see how this is still perfectly legible? That’s the power of a good use of value.
How can you use black and white?
- Ink: the most obvious! Use at as a wash, from a pen, from a brush, or even airbrushed.
- Pencil: a beautifully-rendered pencil drawing is classic
- watercolor: use only black paint in washes to get a full value scale
- colored pencils: stick to black, white, and a range of one type of grey (cool grey, french grey, warm grey)
- collage
- fountain pen inks come in a variety of grey and black tones
- paints (any type)
- markers
- digital
Working in black and white–a student point of view, Elijah Sy
(JMB= Jessica Boehman, ES= Elijah Sy)
JMB: In your Graphic Narrative project, you worked entirely in black and white for your finished project. In the Illustration class, you also did two spots and a full page middle grade illustration for Sleepy Hollow. I want you to think about being forced to work in black in white, even though it seems to be that you prefer it now.
ES: I want to start with my graphic narrative project. I chose to work in black in white because for the story I chose, I wanted to have that feel of a town that is super dead, and the way to show an environment that is bad, where nothing really good happens, is to use dull tones or use a monochromatic approach. For my character, Dominic, black and white seemed like a good fit.
JMB: Do you normally work in black and white?
ES: No, I didn’t normally at this point.
JMB: So, what was the challenge of it?
ES: The challenge was to make it clear and not have the lines get lost in the background. You said, I really need to make some scenes very clear.
JMB: True, you don’t want to be in a situation where the viewer doesn’t know what they are looking at. A good portion of your illustrations you’ve done with white line against a black background. Portions read darkly, starkly.
ES: I mix white lines on a black background for some scenes and in others, I started with a white canvas and used the traditional black line work.

JMB: Did you know you were going to approach it in this way? Did you decide this stylistically as you were working?
ES: I think I was deciding as I went, because working digitally was still new to me. I was using Clip Studio Paint. Sometimes I drew the positive space and others, the negative.
JMB: Did you have fun playing with texture, line work, and value? I see the line work in the shaded areas on Page 5 has this nice section with one hand grabbing on the other character’s arm, and we’ve got some nice changes in line direction in the rendering to keep the illustration clear and not muddy.

ES: I lucked out here as I just played around and found something that looked good to me.
JMB: Now here is an example of a page you made from the Illustration class, where you are working in a similar black and white style, mixing white or black lines against a black background. You use a lot of hatching in the sky, and it makes a nice greyscale, whereas everywhere else it is more stark, which works well to give it a sense of atmosphere. Can you speak to this process?

ES: I first did a white background and I just overlaid black as the shadow for everything, which was hard as I had to keep adjusting the opacity of the layers one-by-one to be sure everything was reading clearly.
JMB: The point of greatest contrast in this image is Ichabod’s face, open mouth, and tongue against the blackness. So your attention gets drawn to his face first, and then your attention gets drawn to the Headless Horseman who is rearing above him, dirt bike style on a CitiBike, with a New York City spin. Do you normally work digitally, or do you experiment with traditional tools as well?
ES: Ooh, I tried my first semester, and I thought it was bad. I thought I did not do well with the ink. It was a struggle. It’s ink.
JMB: Once you put it down you can’t change it.
ES: Yeah, I like the flexibility of having my mistakes me easily erased.
JMB: It also seems like you are leaning into the benefits of digital art, like being able to draw with white on a black background more easily. It’s interesting that you sketched this out in color, but the final is black and white.

ES: This helped me to differentiate in my sketch to not be confused as to which part was which.
JMB: Lastly, for the business card assignment, you also worked in black and white, and chose to use the skeleton of a rat with rat vertebrae as the border.

ES: Well, this was hard as a business card should be some sort of representation of you. I learned that I really enjoyed working in this sort of black and white style, so I decided to use that here as well. My first “bio comic” I showed to class was about rats, so this spoke to me.
JMB: That’s true, you did start that way. Seems like in the process of practicing, you realized that you are good at this and you honed your style. With each assignment, your black and white work got better.
ES: I was intimidated at first, because I had never done it.
JMB: But for other assignments, you worked in pretty vibrant color, like in the book cover assignment, where your cover was picked by the author. Did you find that the lessons you learned by working in black and white helped your color work?

ES: I think it did work in color more easily, because it helped me to think more about contrast and values, and how important it is to have the piece pop.
JMB: In this particular image, the figure of the boy is silhouetted against a burst of light. So it would have worked in black and white as well. So if you desaturated this image, you would see that if your value is done properly, it would still read. This can be a great way to tell if your value is working right.
Media Attributions
- John Martin, Belshazzar’s Feast, from Illustrations of the… © John Martin adapted by Art Institute of Chicago is licensed under a Public Domain license
- Aubrey Beardsley, Study for How a Devil in Woman’s Likeness Would… © https://www.artic.edu/artworks/41036/study-for-how-a-devil-in-woman-s-likeness-would-have-tempted-sir-bors adapted by The Art Institute of Chicago is licensed under a Public Domain license
- Madame X © John Singer Sargent adapted by The Metropolitan Museum of Art is licensed under a CC0 (Creative Commons Zero) license
- John Singer Sargent, “Madame X” (in black and white) © John Singer Sargent adapted by The Metropolitan Museum of Art is licensed under a CC0 (Creative Commons Zero) license
- Elijah Sy, Page 4 © Elijah Sy is licensed under a CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution NonCommercial NoDerivatives) license
- Elijah Sy, Page 5 © Elijah Sy is licensed under a CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution NonCommercial NoDerivatives) license
- Elijah Sy, Ichabod and the Headless Horseman © Elijah Sy is licensed under a CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution NonCommercial NoDerivatives) license
- Elijah Sy, Color Sketch for Ichabod Crane and the Headless Horseman © Elijah Sy is licensed under a CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution NonCommercial NoDerivatives) license
- Elijah Sy, Rat Business Card © Elijah Sy is licensed under a CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution NonCommercial NoDerivatives) license
- Elijah Sy, Brick by Brick cover. © Elijah Sy is licensed under a CC BY-NC-ND (Attribution NonCommercial NoDerivatives) license