Developing Strong Thesis Statements

What It Is, What It Does

The thesis or main claim is the sophisticated response to the central problem or question the writer addresses in his or her essay.

“[T]he purpose of the thesis is to give order both to the reader and to the writer. It does this by clearly stating the central claim that a piece of writing will try to prove [or the conclusion of the analysis conducted in the essay]. The writer takes care in the thesis statement to articulate a paper’s argument as precisely as possible, and this precision clarifies and focuses the direction of the paper. Most of the time, a writer must work with a dynamic thesis statement – one that changes and evolves during the writing process. In other words, a working thesis statement that articulates what a writer is interested in exploring will be enough to guide a writer through a draft of the essay, but the exact words for the thesis statement are not finalized until the paper is nearly complete.” (Moore and Cassel, Techniques for College Writing: The Thesis Statement and Beyond)

Features of Effective Thesis Statements

Effective thesis statements are:

  • Debatable claims with potential counterarguments, but not statements of fact (nor questions).
  • Specific i.e. focused on narrow, clearly defined subjects, using key terms and strong, precise verbs.
  • Supportable using available evidence and reasoning.
  • Insightful i.e. they challenge assumptions and offer new ways of seeing or responding to challenging questions or problems.

Types of Thesis Statements

There are two main types of theses:

  1. A call-to-action thesis makes a recommendation or advocates for a specific course of action, often in response to a controversial social issue or real-life scenario. Call-to-action thesis statements almost always include the words “should,” “must,” “ought” or “recommend.”
  2. An analytical thesis makes a claim about a subject of analysis: a text, an image, or an idea, for example. It reveals and explains a relationship, cause, effect or reason that might seem hidden, counterintuitive or not obvious to a casual reader.

Posing Questions of Your Thesis

In order to develop a strong thesis statement that expresses your central or controlling argument, you will need to pose questions of your thesis and use those questions to revise and rephrase it.

Strong thesis is/does expressive of your central, controlling argument Strong thesis doesn’t list your claims Questions to pose How do my claims collectively express my central argument? Revise and rephrase State your central, controlling argument. Strong thesis is/does specific and precise Strong thesis doesn’t make broad generalizations declare or describe Questions to pose How does my thesis allow for focused analysis and coherence? Revise and rephrase Focus on a specific area of your topic. Add relevant key terms. Strong thesis is/does arguable Strong thesis doesn’t state facts or describe Questions to pose How can my readers engage in a debate with my central argument? Revise and rephrase Present a relevant and specific argument that others might oppose. Strong thesis is/does supportable with evidence Strong thesis doesn’t lack supporting evidence Questions to pose How is my thesis supported by the evidence? Revise and rephrase Review your claims, analysis, and the evidence you’ve included. Strong thesis is/does assertive and confident Strong thesis doesn’t seem reluctant, outrageous, or insulting Questions to pose How convincing is my thesis in asserting an argument about the intellectual problem? Revise and rephrase Rephrase your tone to be assertive and respectful in order to demonstrate your ethos. By Rachael M. Benavidez remixing and adapting from: Horkoff, T. (2021). Writing for Success – 1st Canadian H5P Edition. BCcampus. https://opentextbc.ca/writingforsuccessh5p/ Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Writing About Literature Spring 2024 Copyright © by Rachael Benavidez and Kimberley Garcia is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book